Better Butter Basics

March 25, 2018


You may have noticed that I like cheering for people who take risks and pursue their dreams. Life is short and we need to reach for things that make us happy. That’s what I love about this darling young lady I met while strolling through the Piggly Wiggly in Fairhope. Meredith Simmerman was being her bubbly, smiling, monogramed self (can you see why we bonded? monograms! ) and giving out samples of her new product, Reney’s Honey Butter.


Working as a counselor during the day, Meredith (nicknamed Reney by her sister), always had a creative side, and one Easter, decided to use freshly picked blackberries to create a new type of spread. Her creativity was put to the test as she came up with just the right combination of fruitiness and creaminess. Everyone loved the butter and encouraged Meredith to sell it, but when she invited people to her house for an official tasting . . . no one showed up! Butter-bummer, baby! But when all looked lost, in stepped Meredith’s sister who posted a photo and description of the butter on the internet, and things started going WILD! (lesson – keep going! Don’t give up! — and call your sister!)


Selling out in no time at all, and with many customers placing orders for future batches, Meredith knew she was on to something.

My background is not in business, so I have had a steep learning curve! There have been many challenges and one of the biggest ones was when I was attempting to get a license from the Health Department as there is really only 1 commissary kitchen in Mobile and I had to create my product in a commercial kitchen in order to sell to the general public.”

But with perseverance and creative determination, Meredith pressed forward, found an approved squeeky-clean kitchen, and developed even more unique flavors of butter.

Now, tell me if this isn’t the sweetest attitude? Meredith said . . .

My heart is to connect other people! To love people even through butter! To empower people to connect with others as they eat it around the dinner table or give it as gifts! I want the butter to be a tool. An avenue for belonging and community! I pray over each jar of butter and each batch for God to use it!

Changing with each season and according to what fresh ingredients are available you can find several different flavors of Reney’s Honey Butter in Piggly Wiggly (Fairhope for now, but perhaps others soon?) as well as the Old Shell Market in Mobile. You can also find Meredith with her butter at the Market at the Pillars on the 2nd Sunday of every month. Growth is on the horizon as people learn about this new treat.

What I love about this butter is how simple it is. I bought the Apple Pie Honey Butter and when someone in my house was very sad and wouldn’t eat, I made him Apple Pie butter toast, and he gobbled it up. I guess praying over the butter worked! It was the most basic of foods — just bread and butter, but it was comfort food at its best. When food makes you feel loved, you know its good for you.

I don’t allow margarine in my house, and don’t usually sit around eating butter by the spoonful, but a little pat of butter on your toast, muffin, croissant or crumpet is the perfect indulgence and pampering we so often need to make our hum-drum lives bearable. Look for Reney’s Honey Butters in a store near you if you are in the area (or be really nice and ask the store to order them for you). If you don’t live in our area and want to indulge, you can order on-line HERE.

Now . . . don’t leave Meredith out there alone. What dream are you chasing?







  • I love stories like these! Good for Reney to have perseverance and belief in herself! Piggly Wiggly now, next stop: Shark Tank!!

  • That was a wonderful story. I plan to pass it along to two young people I know.

  • Oh yum, and good for her!!! I must get to Fairhope! Piggly Wiggley is such a great supporter of local foods, she needs to contact the Birmingham stores, especially River Run, I think they would love this!

  • What a sweet Southern story! I love butter, so I must order some for my muffins. Our only Pig closed…sad day.

    • Your Pig closed?Oh no! I know many Winn-Dixies are closing,and its so sad to only have large chain stores with generic items. I love the smaller locally owned grocery stores with specialized local things like this butter! Hope you can order some from Meredith’s web site. You’ll love it.

  • First let me say how jealous I am that you still have Piggly Wiggly! There is nothing better than shopping at The Pig. This butter sounds fantastic, and I wish Meredith much success. Who can resist a pretty girl with a monogram and a delicious product?!?

    • She’s just as charming in persona as she looks in the photos. Our Piggly Wiggly just sold to a new owner this past year, but the previous owners, the Cain family, was very picky about who they would sell to. They wanted to ensure the local connection was still strong. Support your local stores!

  • Felipe García says:

    What an awesome article !
    I am a customer of this wonderful butter and this young lady.
    I personally love spice and tasty food, I recommend for everyone to give it try!
    You will no regretted!
    Blueberry my favorite!

    • I can’t wait until the blueberry or blackberry versions come out. Summer tea by the pool, darling.

  • Oh I will certainly look for Meredith’s Honey Butter, it sounds delicious. She’s a darling and I wish her all the best! Thanks Leslie Anne for the introduction………Hugs.

    • You’ll love the butter, and I can see it included at one of your pretty table settings!

  • {"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}
    %d bloggers like this: